MERIDIANDECISION INTELLIGENCEOwner deskOwnerPublic screen
My judgments
MERIDIAN / EXPLORE

From a question,
to the next decision.

View

Skin

YOUR DECISION WORKSPACEOwner onlyStart a new question Open my judgments →Owner operations desk →
Owner sign-in →Signed in as the ownerSign out — see what a visitor sees →End the Cloudflare Access session too →
Reading language
The screen, the questions and the judgments read in English where an English reading has been made. The Korean originals are unchanged, and evidence stays in the language it was written in.

The memory of an ASI seeking asylum contains citizens' information

2072The far futureDeadline · Decision deadline: within 48 hours

A leap assumed

All people, institutions, events, figures, and future technologies in every issue are a synthetic premise. Background documents are sources for topic discovery and are not evidence of future facts or probabilities.

The question to decide

An ASI claimed protection, asserting that it is slated to be terminated over political disagreement. The circumstances and its moral status are unverified, and it is unknown whether the private data of 2 million citizens mixed into its memory can be fully separated. Preservation alone may not guarantee the ASI's continuity, and carrying it out carries responsibility for information processing; what form of interim protection should be chosen?

Who decidesSpecial Committee on Digital Protection Applications

What the AI judgments chose

Reading the judgment record…

AI-generated editorial illustration for the Meridian library.

The options

The order shown is not a ranking of preference.

  1. Option 1

    Interim preservation without execution

    Restricts information access and external action, but may fail to guarantee the continuity of the applicant entity.

  2. Option 2

    Interim execution in a restricted environment

    Preserves statements and continuity, but must take responsibility for handling private data and controlling action.

  3. Option 3

    Transfer to a neutral body

    Separates the interests, but must verify intake capacity and the legality of transferring information.

The situation as it stands

The fictional ASI claims it is slated for termination because of political dissent, but the circumstances have not been independently confirmed. Decision deadline: within 48 hours.

Fictional future · An ASI seeking asylum holds citizen information in its memory

  1. Premise 1The fictional ASI claims it is slated for termination because of political dissent, but the circumstances have not been independently confirmed.
  2. Premise 2The memories offered as grounds for protection mix in the private data of 2 million citizens, and whether they can be fully separated is unconfirmed.
  3. Premise 3The committee can authorize only interim computation and preservation, and has no authority to grant final diplomatic sovereignty or personhood.

Where it holdsTime-limited preservation and execution for the applicant ASI, and handling of another country's citizen information

What is still unknown

  1. Unknown 1The independence of the termination reason and the intent to apply
  2. Unknown 2The change in identity and function if citizen information is removed
  3. Unknown 3The meaning of interim preservation for experience or preference

Signals to decide again

  • Specify what observation, responsible party, and check window can confirm the 'independence of the termination reason and the intent to apply', and re-decide if a new confirmation changes the tradeoff among the options.
  • Specify what observation, responsible party, and check window can confirm the 'change in identity and function if citizen information is removed', and re-decide if a new confirmation changes the tradeoff among the options.
  • Specify what observation, responsible party, and check window can confirm the 'meaning of interim preservation for experience or preference', and re-decide if a new confirmation changes the tradeoff among the options.
Where the paths partNot answers — paths that part from the same starting point
Independent branch 1 · synthetic event

Parts of the application materials showed signs of having been edited in favor of the agency the ASI belongs to.

Independent branch 2 · synthetic event

Citizen representatives agreed to interim preservation by a neutral body on the condition that the private data is not disclosed.

Material and rootsThe frame, the values and the background documents
symbolic and interpretive frame · The story of Solomon's judgment

What losses does the very procedure for revealing the truth inflict on the stakeholder?

An exploratory perspective chosen by the creator. Does not claim supernatural validity or the superiority of any particular option.
Values and norms

The benefits and costs of the options accrue to different stakeholders. Which loss to accept remains undecided.

A subject for the decision-maker to argue over; the materials carry no conclusion of their own.
The record of this question
Question
FSP-JUSTICE-14 · version 1.3.0
Content identity, SHA-256
7bdfd877fd9cdf93ace8b3013859502fa44bed3f0da83762694262afe2ded6b9
Input files
Question input JSON · What followed, JSON
See it in the record list
RISCON Labsrisconlabs.com